Connect with us

Subscribe

Photo by Berk on Unsplash

Leadership + Society

Borrowing reputation is a double-edged sword

A Swing and a Miss

Canadians rarely get upset. When they do, sports or repeated threats to their sovereignty are usually to blame. In 2025, Vladimir Guerrero Jr., the Dominican-Canadian baseball star, signed an eye-watering $500 million contract with the Toronto Blue Jays, the largest in team history. Following a lackluster 2026 season, Guerrero’s comments on a Spanish-language podcast managed to cause quite a stir, even among Canada’s more cerebral audiences.

“The money they [the Blue Jays organization] gave me wasn’t for what I’m going to do. It was for what I already did,” was how Guerrero justified the negative return on investment during the first season of his new mega-deal. At the urging of his Hall of Fame father, Guerrero was quick to walk back on his remarks and issue a public apology to teammates and fans alike.

The belief that past heroics bestow lasting authority and justify outsized rewards in the present transcends the world of sports.

On LinkedIn, where puffery, virtue-signalling, mundane situations recast as profound moments of professional transformation, and AI bots gone rogue have become commonplace, some users have opted to distinguish themselves by displaying their past institutional affiliations in their headlines, especially when those include a well-known employer.

These shorthand markers of pedigree – or ‘ex-labels’ – serve several purposes. At their core, however, they fit Guerrero’s logic to a tee: the notion that professional standing is largely conferred by past accomplishments, irrespective of how well, or poorly, someone is currently performing

Identity anchoring gone wrong

There is nothing inherently wrong with leveraging former associations to signal credibility and position oneself as a safe bet in a competitive and crowded job market.

As the proud bearer of Müller – the most common surname in Germany and Switzerland, and one shared by three families unrelated by blood on my childhood street alone – I can readily relate to the instinct of wanting to distinguish one’s personal brand.

Of course, borrowing the credibility of others to bolster one’s own can just as easily leave a less favourable impression. The cult-like devotion that some employees display toward their employers in public can not only be off-putting but become a bit of a headscratcher when that same devotion and free advertisement last long after the paycheques have stopped coming in.

The borrowing of reputational capital should serve a purpose other than individual gain.

Having one’s personal and professionally identity so closely intertwined with an inanimate entity also carries an unspoken risk, as organizations are prone to violent reputational fluctuations. Whereas ‘ex-Google’, ‘ex-Goldman Sachs’, or ‘ex-McKinsey’ remain coveted badges of honour among LinkedIn users, ‘ex-FTX’, ‘ex-Theranos’ or ‘ex-Weinstein Company’ labels have gone out of fashion – for obvious reasons.

For entrepreneurs in particular, leaning too heavily on the credentials and achievements of others can ultimately be counterproductive. While reputation-borrowing can be invaluable during an organization’s pre-seed and early start-up stages, relying on it for too long can prevent a unique organizational identity and genuine competitive capabilities from taking shape.

After some time, doubts arise whether the new enterprise is built on anything other than borrowed credibility, rather than its own ability to create value.

A sub-par vineyard in Tuscany or along the Mosel, for example, may initially benefit from the prestige associated with these historic wine-growing regions and able to sell its products. But it is unlikely to endure once people realize what a good Chianti or Riesling should taste like. When borrowed prestige is not matched by underlying quality or performance, investor confidence and public trust erode, quickly and often irreversibly.

The case for borrowed name recognition

Notable family lineages, affiliations with prestigious institutions, and credentials or honorifics of any kind – those who have them, typically use them for their personal advantage and economic gain in some form or another. So long as the borrowed trust is reflective of actual achievements and abilities and does not rest on a case of excellence by mere association, there is, in my view, little reason to challenge the practice itself, however deeply inequitable it may be.

While social media and corporate culture could do with a little less prestige signalling, one industry could stand to embrace the practice of reputation transfer more enthusiastically.

In philanthropy, the relationship between funders and the recipients of philanthropic dollars is often depicted as just that: a financial transaction that garners headlines largely because of the monetary amounts involved. In reality, philanthropists’ ability to affect positive change within their chosen focus areas extends far beyond the lending of financial lifelines to deserving nonprofits and social enterprises.

To help organizations scale and turn their innovations into policies, market mechanisms, business models, or social behaviours capable of wide-spread adoption, capital injections, ideally the flexible and unrestricted kind, are helpful but often not enough. Established funders should also use their reputation, expertise, and networks to strengthen the independence of their delivery partners.

The Ivey Foundation, a 1947-founded family foundation, has done exactly that in Canada and more. By choosing to forego perpetuity in favour of a rapid wind-up window, Ivey made a deliberate decision to deploy the remaining $100 million of its endowment by the end of 2027. These funds went to a carefully selected number of grantees, some of which had been created by the foundation itself. In doing so, Ivey consciously transfused both its legacy name and catalytic capital into an emerging ecosystem focused on clean energy, the net-zero transition, and climate action, one that can now comfortably stand, scale, and attract funding on its own.

The erosion of traditional trust signals

Whether in baseball, social media, start-ups, or philanthropy, the borrowing of reputational capital should serve a purpose other than individual gain and, where appropriate, be temporary.

Crucially, any credibility gained through association must ultimately be underpinned by the quality, substance, and excellence of the work itself in order to maintain its positive momentum long into the future. This is especially true given that traditional trust signals no longer carry the same weight they once did.

The automatic credibility that legacy brands, credentials, or endorsements once commanded is increasingly being challenged by tech-savvy 21st century audiences who are more discerning and skeptical of marketing theatrics – especially those used to mask mediocre quality and performance.

Newsletter Signup

Written By

Dr Tim Mueller is the founder and Managing Director of Chester & Fourth, a Canadian advisory firm that partners with mission-driven organizations and leaders around the world.

Advertisement

UNESCO World Philosophy Day: Why we still need to think deeply about the world

See Differently

Ten years in. Just getting started.

Build What Matters

€1.8bn earmarked for Europe’s next generation of deep-tech innovators

Frontier Technology

Europe’s next generation of innovators: EIT Jumpstarter announces 2026 winners

Build What Matters

Connect
Newsletter Signup